If you’ve heard of the lipstick index, you are well aware: The recession doesn’t stop beauty mavens from wanting to stock up on goodies. To keep finances intact and your beauty bar full, consider these makeup finds under $5...

Despite what you've seen on other price tags, all-natural beauty can be had for less. E.l.f. Mineral Eyeshadows ($3 at EyesLipsFace.com), for instance, offers translucent eye shades that will hydrate and minimize the appearance of fine lines without parabens, preservatives and chemical dyes.

—Aly Walansky